The 10 Best Mailboxes

Sara Mandeed
Written by
Last update:

Chances are, sooner than later, you’ve felt like you were at your wits end trying to manage all the mail that comes into your house. You hate wasting your time sorting through junk mail, but your mailman doesn’t help by just plopping the whole stack on the mat. Your current mailbox is way too big to keep organized, but switching to a post office mailbox will cost you a fortune.

Where to begin?

We’ve tackled the mailbox dilemma and found the best mailboxes for you in 2021.

NameCategoryProduct
Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security MailboxBest OverallMail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox
Gibraltar Mailboxes Elite Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel WhiteBudget PickGibraltar Mailboxes Elite Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel White
Architectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel MailboxUpgrade PickArchitectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel Mailbox

1. Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox

Our rating: 9 / 10

Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • 24-hour, seven-day-a-week customer service
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Easy installation
  • Option to choose between two different locking systems
  • Available in matte and glossy finish

2 Tray.

Mail Boss 7506 Curbside Locking Security Mailbox, Black, Large.

The first mailbox and our number one pick is the Mail Boss 7506. What we love about this mailbox is that it is sealed with laminate, which prevents water from getting inside during rain, sleet, or snow.

2. Gibraltar Mailboxes Brighton Galvanized Steel Black

Our rating: 9 / 10

Gibraltar Mailboxes Brighton Galvanized Steel Black

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Made from galvanized steel
  • Classic oval shape
  • Includes mounting screws
  • Simple yet attractive design
  • Available in five colors
  • Easily customizable
  • Durable powder-coated finish
  • Made in the USA
  • Four-digit combination lock

Cons:

  • Lock mechanism not as sturdy as it could be
  • Handles a little too close to the ground
  • No mounting gear included

The post and mailbox set from Gibraltar are both made from galvanized steel, which is known to be one of the most durable metals you can choose when it comes to outdoor mailboxes. It has a classic oval shape, so it compliments any residential setting. Overall, it has a simple yet attractive design. The Gibraltar Mailboxes can be customized according to your needs as you have the freedom to choose a combination lock with the option of selecting one of five colors.

This mail/post combo set has been made in the USA. The whole mailbox has been painted in a black powder-coating to prevent corrosion and give it a sleek appearance. Because you can easily change the combination to customize the mailbox, it can be used for various purposes.

The handle of the mailbox is at a decent height, but you might find it a little too close to the ground. The Gibraltar mailbox set also lacks mounting gears, which you might consider buying separately.

3. Step2 541200 MailMaster Plus Mailbox

Our rating: 9 / 10

Step2 541200 MailMaster Plus Mailbox

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Sturdy and high quality
  • Large capacity
  • Powder-coated steel is durable and resists rust
  • Expandable for various needs
  • Easy to assemble
  • ADA-compliant
  • Large friendly-looking face on the mailbox
  • Comes with a 3-step locking door
  • Convenient paper holder
  • Includes a digital lock with two keys

Cons:

  • Heavy at 25 pounds
  • Will not work with Amazon Key
  • Lock if not Amazon is sold separately

This large capacity mailbox from Step2 is designed for a variety of uses and comes at an exceptional value. The steel construction comes ready to be assembled in about fifteen to twenty minutes and is very sturdy. It has an underbody access door and a three-step locking door, which can be locked with a digital lock.

The powder-coated steel construction makes it highly rust proof and durable, providing this useful mailbox with excellent protection against the elements. This Step2 mailbox offers an adjustable shelf for additional storage when you need it.

4. Gibraltar Mailboxes Woodlands Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel Black

Our rating: 9 / 10

Gibraltar Mailboxes Woodlands Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel Black

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Made from leading-grade galvanized steel
  • Elegant matte black powder coating
  • Rust-proof brass hinges and latch for smooth operation
  • Sturdy walls that prevent letters from falling out
  • Wall mounting options available
  • Powder-coated, antiqued iron medallion accents
  • Easy installation process

Keeping your mailbox in good condition is a must. One of the best ways to do that is to buy a high-quality mail holder. In our search for the best mailboxes, we’ve found that the Woodlands Medium-Capacity Mailbox from Gibraltar Mailboxes can take the abuse, is easy to install, and looks great on the outside.

This mailbox is made from high-grade galvanized steel, and it comes in a matte black powder-coated finish that makes it blend in with the surroundings. It’s surprisingly lightweight, so it works well if you’re installing it in an area that requires you to mount it on a wall. However, you can also stand it on a flat surface if desired. Just be sure to use a stand on softer surfaces like grass if you’re going to install it on-ground.

5. Architectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel Mailbox

Our rating: 8 / 10

Architectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel Mailbox

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Durable powder coat finish
  • Secure, locking mailbox
  • Easy to attach to your post
  • Includes step-by-step instructions for mounting
  • Has a lock that’s easy to use
  • Has an aesthetically-pleasing design
  • Holds over 31 cubic feet of mail

Cons:

  • Mail is not retrievable when locked
  • Colors may chip over time

We’ve got a good feeling about this mailbox. The Architectural Mailboxes Oasis Banbury Post Mount Modern Locking Mailbox with Black Powder Coated Finish is a stylish mailbox that has lockable convenience. It’s elegant style won’t give your home the look of an apartment complex.

This mailbox is made of powder coated steel, which makes it tamper-proof and moisture-resistant so you don’t have to worry about rusting and can avoid the need for paint. The locking mailbox comes with a 2-3/8” x 24 notched cam and a 21” dead bolt locking mechanism that give it a secure feel. It’s easy to mount as it comes with detailed instructions and all of the necessary mounting hardware.

6. Gibraltar Mailboxes BM16BSN1 Brunswick Rural Mailbox

Our rating: 8 / 10

Gibraltar Mailboxes BM16BSN1 Brunswick Rural Mailbox

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Made out of durable steel
  • Extra-strong door latch
  • Heavy-duty powder finish to prevent scratches and rust
  • Available in different colors
  • 3-Year Warranty
  • Easy assembly // Installation services available for free

Cons:

  • Heavy
  • Door latch is mounted on one side only

We are impressed with this mailbox and strongly recommend it to anyone looking for the best rural mailboxes. The mailbox is made of sturdy steel, and its powder finish prevents scratches and corrosion. It comes in six different colors. The satin nickel finish is especially popular among buyers as it matches their front door.

The Gibraltar mailbox is extremely durable making it a good option for use in a rural area. It is especially popular among contractors and people living near busy roads who need a strong mailbox. The manufacturer offers a 3-year warranty.

The Gibraltar mailbox has an easy to install mounting system, and you will need at least two people to do the job. Directions are provided, and mounting services are available for free.

7. Architectural Mailboxes 6300B-10 Oasis 360 Locking Parcel Mailbox

Our rating: 8 / 10

Architectural Mailboxes 6300B-10 Oasis 360 Locking Parcel Mailbox

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Holds up to 275 pounds
  • Available in black or tan
  • 10-year extended warranty
  • Lifetime residential warranty
  • Offered in several different sizes
  • Interior light
  • Spacious design
  • Easy to install
  • Available in powder-coated or cast aluminum
  • Batteries are included

Cons:

  • Not suitable for high-traffic areas
  • Some users have reported leaks
  • Expensive batteries

(Discontinued by Manufacturer)

8. Gibraltar Mailboxes Stanley Extra-Large Capacity Galvanized Steel Black

Our rating: 7 / 10

Gibraltar Mailboxes Stanley Extra-Large Capacity Galvanized Steel Black

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to put together
  • Optional replacement parts
  • Contemporary design
  • Easy to mount to a post
  • Fits large batches of mail
  • Doesn’t rust, mildew, or collect snow
  • Great customer service

Cons:

  • Some pieces of the mailbox are easy to break
  • Rust spots may appear overtime
  • Tracking information for delivery

We found the very first mailbox to be the hardest to find so we decided a list was in order.

We tried to choose different styles of mailboxes for different types of individuals living in different environments and lifestyles. We made sure to list mailboxes that were durable and would last a lifetime. Of course the price varied depending on the style, material, and features of the mailboxes.

Our first pick was made with ease of assembly in mind, it helps that the box comes apart into pieces which helps keep things less confusing. It also comes with a tracking number to help you know when you will receive your mailbox.

9. Gibraltar Mailboxes Patriot Large Capacity Rust-Proof Plastic Black

Our rating: 6 / 10

Gibraltar Mailboxes Patriot Large Capacity Rust-Proof Plastic Black

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Convenient location
  • Large capacity
  • Gorgeous paint job
  • Comes fully assembled
  • Space efficient and an attractive design
  • Content theft resistant
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Locks on both mailbox doors
  • Safe and secure
  • Made of high-quality plastic

10. ADDRESSES OF DISTINCTION Charleston Large Mailbox & Post System

Our rating: 6 / 10

ADDRESSES OF DISTINCTION Charleston Large Mailbox & Post System

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Overall a sturdy and elegant design
  • Attractive metal finish with attractive scroll work & pineapple finial accessories
  • Solid all-metal construction
  • Includes mounting hardware
  • Has adhesive nameplate
  • Mailbox and optional address plaque are both constructed of metal
  • Perfect for on-the-spot delivery of bills, cards, and invoices
  • Receiver enclosures are gasketed for non-corrosion

Cons:

  • Pineapple finial is only suited for flat tops and only comes in bronze color
  • Included adhesive name plate is not ready to be used, and the mounting holes in the name plate are a bit too small, so it doesn’t offer the full look as it should

11. Gibraltar Mailboxes Elite Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel White

Our rating: 6 / 10

Gibraltar Mailboxes Elite Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel White

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Solidly built, with excellent capacity
  • The best of the best galvanized steel mailbox
  • Very good value for money
  • Comes with mailbox post and mounting hardware
  • Locked with 6-pin cylinder key
  • Powder coated

Cons:

  • One report of paint chipping off
  • No delivery to Alaska and Hawaii

If you're looking for the best mailboxes for your home or office, there's a lot to consider. We looked at a variety of factors when assessing mailboxes, including durability, value, weight, and capacity. Of course, all of these factors are important to consider, but the capacity of a mailbox can sometimes vary widely depending on who makes it.

Our team of experts found that one of the best mailboxes for home use is the Gibraltar Elite in medium capacity. This mailbox is made from galvanized steel, and is very well constructed. It's also incredibly sturdy, which is important for a mailbox you have hanging right on your property line.

Gibraltar offers a wide range of mailboxes, from ones that can hold only a few pieces of mail to those that can hold several newspapers. We think the medium capacity is best for home use. If you're purchasing a mailbox for your home office, you may want to consider a slightly bigger mailbox.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best locking mailbox?

This depends on your needs, but overall the USPS approved Lockable City Mailbox from Post Office Plastic is our pick for a locking mailbox on Amazon. This is the most secure locking mailbox we have found.

It features a 4-digit combination lock that allows you to access your boxes from the front or back.

This is the largest capacity locking mailbox of the bunch with over 13 cubic feet of storage. The price is the same as the standard model.

Where is the best place to buy a mailbox?

You can buy a mailbox from your local hardware store, big box store, home improvement store, or home improvement center. It's like the old saying “where there's a will, there's a way.” And, this is especially true if you need to buy a mailbox.

Personally, I've always felt that buying your mailbox from the place where they specialize in mailboxes is probably your best bet, and sure enough, it is.

So, if you're looking for the best option available give Mr. Mailbox a visit. They have great service, great prices, and of course, great selection.

What are the different types of mailboxes?

Metal – This type of mailbox is classic and is often seen in all cities and streets. The material is sturdy, and it encourages privacy, especially if it is mounted in a corner. The downside is that, due to the material, it can be difficult to paint which means you have to pick a color that will match your surroundings.

Wood – These are also classic designs and can last a lifetime if properly maintained. Their downside is that the paint usually does not last long as it fades easily. When using wood, you need to choose a stain that will last long without peeling off easily.

What size mailbox do I need?

I would advise you to go with the larger size mailbox. It is more practical and will certainly come in handy. In the future, there is a higher chance of success that you will buy something off these days. In the event that you do receive anything in the mail, you’ll need a bigger box. Buy big in the event of any problem.

Conclusion

The Mailboxes we have recommended are the best in their class. If you follow our criterion, the selected ones will serve their purpose for a long time. We have scrutinized them based on their available options, size, durability, price, and many other factors. So, if you are looking for a mailbox for you, you should definitely read our reviews before you make a buying decision.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Mail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security MailboxBest OverallMail Boss 7506 Mail Manager Curbside Locking Security Mailbox
Gibraltar Mailboxes Elite Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel WhiteBudget PickGibraltar Mailboxes Elite Medium Capacity Galvanized Steel White
Architectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel MailboxUpgrade PickArchitectural Mailboxes 6200B-10 Oasis Classic Locking Post Mount Parcel Mailbox